Spike Week
  • Tools
    • DraftIQ
      • NFL
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
      • NBA
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
      • MLB
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
      • PGA
      • CFB
      • CBB
      • NHL
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
    • Draft Hacker
    • Tournament DB
      • NFL
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTKINGS
        • DRAFTERS
      • NBA
        • DRAFTERS
      • MLB
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
    • My Draft Planner
    • Tournament Selector
    • Ownership Projections
    • Playoff Schedule Cheat Sheet
      • NFL
      • CFB
    • Bye Week Cheat Sheet
      • NFL
      • CFB
    • NFL Stack Matrix
    • Stats
      • Best Ball Stats
      • Spike Week Stats
        • NFL
        • NBA
        • MLB
        • CFB
        • PGA
      • Player Weekly Scores
  • Rankings
    • Rankings Hub
      • NFL
      • NBA
      • MLB
      • PGA
      • CFB
      • CBB
    • NFL
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
        • Underdog SuperFlex
        • Underdog Playoff
        • Underdog Eliminator
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Standard
        • Drafters Superflex
        • Drafters Playoff
      • DraftKings
        • Draftkings Standard
      • FastDraft
        • FastDraft Standard
      • 2025 Rookie Rankings
    • NBA
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
        • Underdog Playoffs
      • DraftKings
        • Draftkings Standard
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Standard
        • Drafters Playoff
    • MLB
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
        • Underdog Playoff
        • Underdog Eliminator
      • Draftkings
        • Draftkings Standard
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Standard
    • PGA
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
    • CBB
      • Underdog
        • Underdog March Madness
    • CFB
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
  • Strategy
    • 2025 NFL Strategy Hub
    • NFL
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Tournament Strategy
        • Underdog Marathon Strategy
        • Underdog Sprint Strategy
        • Underdog Weekly Winners Strategy
        • Underdog SuperFlex Strategy
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Tournament Strategy
      • DraftKings
        • DraftKings Tournament Strategy
        • Draftkings Playoff
      • FastDraft
        • FastDraft Flex 4 Strategy
      • Zero RB Draft Strategy
      • Hero RB Draft Strategy
      • SuperHero RB Draft Strategy
      • Robust RB Draft Strategy
      • Contingent Value for NFL Best Ball
      • How to Draft Like You’re Right
      • Maximizing Playoff Upside for Best Ball Tournaments
      • Scenario Based Upside
      • The Moneyball Approach to NFL Best Ball
      • How to Auto Draft NFL Teams
      • Exploitative Best Ball Strategy
      • The Best Ball Triple Option
      • How to Use the NFL Schedule & Playoff Stacking
    • NBA
      • How to Play NBA Best Ball Tournaments
      • How to Play Underdog NBA Playoff Best Ball
      • 2025 Underdog Playoff Best Ball Strategy
      • 2025 Drafters Playoff Best Ball Strategy
      • Team Breakdown for 2025 NBA Playoff Best Ball
      • My 2025 NBA Playoff Bracket
      • Underdog NBA Data Driven Strategy Guide
    • MLB
      • How to Play MLB Best Ball
      • Underdog MLB Data Driven Strategy Guide
      • How To Play MLB Playoff Best Ball
    • PGA
      • How to Play PGA Golf Best Ball
  • Promos
    • Drafters Promo Code (100% Deposit Bonus)
    • Free Month of Spike Week w/ Drafters Deposit
    • Underdog Fantasy Promo (100% Bonus)
  • Tools Tutorials
    • How to Install the Draft Hacker
    • How to Update the Draft Hacker
    • How to Sync Your Underdog Account to the Draft Hacker
    • How to Customize Your Draft Hacker Settings
    • How to use the Draft Hacker in your Drafts
    • How to Upload Your Best Ball Teams to the Draft Hacker
    • Mobile Draft Hacker Tutorial
    • DraftIQ
      • DraftIQ Basics
  • Draft Hacker Settings
  • Subscribe
    • Discord Only
  • Account
  • Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Tools
    • DraftIQ
      • NFL
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
      • NBA
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
      • MLB
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
      • PGA
      • CFB
      • CBB
      • NHL
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
        • DRAFTKINGS
    • Draft Hacker
    • Tournament DB
      • NFL
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTKINGS
        • DRAFTERS
      • NBA
        • DRAFTERS
      • MLB
        • UNDERDOG
        • DRAFTERS
    • My Draft Planner
    • Tournament Selector
    • Ownership Projections
    • Playoff Schedule Cheat Sheet
      • NFL
      • CFB
    • Bye Week Cheat Sheet
      • NFL
      • CFB
    • NFL Stack Matrix
    • Stats
      • Best Ball Stats
      • Spike Week Stats
        • NFL
        • NBA
        • MLB
        • CFB
        • PGA
      • Player Weekly Scores
  • Rankings
    • Rankings Hub
      • NFL
      • NBA
      • MLB
      • PGA
      • CFB
      • CBB
    • NFL
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
        • Underdog SuperFlex
        • Underdog Playoff
        • Underdog Eliminator
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Standard
        • Drafters Superflex
        • Drafters Playoff
      • DraftKings
        • Draftkings Standard
      • FastDraft
        • FastDraft Standard
      • 2025 Rookie Rankings
    • NBA
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
        • Underdog Playoffs
      • DraftKings
        • Draftkings Standard
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Standard
        • Drafters Playoff
    • MLB
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
        • Underdog Playoff
        • Underdog Eliminator
      • Draftkings
        • Draftkings Standard
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Standard
    • PGA
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
    • CBB
      • Underdog
        • Underdog March Madness
    • CFB
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Standard
  • Strategy
    • 2025 NFL Strategy Hub
    • NFL
      • Underdog
        • Underdog Tournament Strategy
        • Underdog Marathon Strategy
        • Underdog Sprint Strategy
        • Underdog Weekly Winners Strategy
        • Underdog SuperFlex Strategy
      • Drafters
        • Drafters Tournament Strategy
      • DraftKings
        • DraftKings Tournament Strategy
        • Draftkings Playoff
      • FastDraft
        • FastDraft Flex 4 Strategy
      • Zero RB Draft Strategy
      • Hero RB Draft Strategy
      • SuperHero RB Draft Strategy
      • Robust RB Draft Strategy
      • Contingent Value for NFL Best Ball
      • How to Draft Like You’re Right
      • Maximizing Playoff Upside for Best Ball Tournaments
      • Scenario Based Upside
      • The Moneyball Approach to NFL Best Ball
      • How to Auto Draft NFL Teams
      • Exploitative Best Ball Strategy
      • The Best Ball Triple Option
      • How to Use the NFL Schedule & Playoff Stacking
    • NBA
      • How to Play NBA Best Ball Tournaments
      • How to Play Underdog NBA Playoff Best Ball
      • 2025 Underdog Playoff Best Ball Strategy
      • 2025 Drafters Playoff Best Ball Strategy
      • Team Breakdown for 2025 NBA Playoff Best Ball
      • My 2025 NBA Playoff Bracket
      • Underdog NBA Data Driven Strategy Guide
    • MLB
      • How to Play MLB Best Ball
      • Underdog MLB Data Driven Strategy Guide
      • How To Play MLB Playoff Best Ball
    • PGA
      • How to Play PGA Golf Best Ball
  • Promos
    • Drafters Promo Code (100% Deposit Bonus)
    • Free Month of Spike Week w/ Drafters Deposit
    • Underdog Fantasy Promo (100% Bonus)
  • Tools Tutorials
    • How to Install the Draft Hacker
    • How to Update the Draft Hacker
    • How to Sync Your Underdog Account to the Draft Hacker
    • How to Customize Your Draft Hacker Settings
    • How to use the Draft Hacker in your Drafts
    • How to Upload Your Best Ball Teams to the Draft Hacker
    • Mobile Draft Hacker Tutorial
    • DraftIQ
      • DraftIQ Basics
  • Draft Hacker Settings
  • Subscribe
    • Discord Only
  • Account
  • Log In
No Result
View All Result
Spike Week
No Result
View All Result
Home NFL Written

When to Draft Best Ball Tournament Teams – Fantasy Football & Best Ball Strategy

by Erik Beimfohr
October 27, 2022

Particularly since the introduction of big NFL Best Ball contests and tournaments across the industry, it’s been a fairly hot debate about when you actually should be drafting. Draft too early, and you invite quite a bit more injury risk and uncertainty while possibly missing out on some new values that pop up in training camp and preseason. Draft too late, and you miss on some of the best value of the entire draft season in terms of average draft position (ADP).

I’m sure plenty think they have the perfect answer, but the truth is there isn’t one. There is merit to drafting at all sorts of different times, and it’s largely up to each individual to assess their risk tolerance and potential edge at different parts of the draft calendar. There are also a few different factors to consider when evaluating when to draft your Best Ball Tournament teams, whether that be on Underdog Fantasy, Drafters, DraftKings or elsewhere.

Tournament Format

The first thing to consider for when to draft your teams is the format that you’re playing in. Most best ball tournaments are what I’d call the “playoff format”, where you play in a 12 team league against the teams you drafted against, and if you advance from that group you have to win against other advancing teams in 3 individual weeks (Week 15-17). This is what we see on Underdog, DraftKings and FFPC.

The other format is what I would call the “cumulative format”, which is what we see on Drafters. In this format, you simply draft your team and then compete against every other team in the entire tournament to accumulate the most fantasy points over the course of the entire season. While in the playoff format, those final 3 weeks are where all the money is made, in the cumulative game week 1 is worth just as much as week 17. They’re extremely different games.

Due to these differences, there can be different approaches to timing of drafts, as well. Jack Miller from Establish The Run did an awesome study earlier this offseason about this subject, and the key takeaway was that teams drafted later score more fantasy points on average. They also score more fantasy points at some of the top percentile outcomes. This all makes a ton of sense when we consider that players inevitably get hurt during the offseason (and sink teams drafted earlier), and we learn so much more about roles, depth charts, etc. the closer we get to the season. All of that information allows us to draft more strongly projected teams that avoided the offseason landmines like Cam Akers or Michael Thomas.

Because of that, I would lean a bit more heavily in the cumulative format on later drafts. Personally, I would not entirely ignore the early drafts in this format because I would want to have access to at least a few “lottery ticket” type teams before ADP settles and the offseason chaos ensues. It gives you shots at what I like to call a “Super Team” that largely just gets lucky and benefits from the chaos of an NFL offseason and best ball draft cycle. However, I would lean more heavily on later drafts because of the large boost in projected points. You are obviously going to need to hit on most of the “league winners” from that season, but the added boost of ensuring you’re getting much stronger projections right out of the gate is extremely important when the early weeks count the same as every other week.

In the playoff format, I think more of a barbell approach (something I wrote about last year) makes a lot more sense. When you have a tournament that is open for such an extended period of time, you end up having unique combinations of players that can only get drafted during certain pockets of time. The pockets that are the smallest in terms of unique combos are at the very start and near the end of the draft season. When the tournament opens, we have new or stale ADP, so the sharp players from the market swoop in and drastically shift the inefficient ADP to more efficient levels. When the tournament is near closing, we are gaining a lot more new information from training camp, preseason, etc. that swings ADP because we now can more accurately project many situations. We typically see a bit weaker competition (more casual players) piling in closer to the start of the season, so there’s also theoretically a skill edge at that point.

(One note from my experience last season and talking to other players is that later drafts on Underdog and Drafters did not seem to have any real skill edge like we had hoped, but that skill edge in late drafts on DraftKings was MASSIVE.)

On top of that, in the playoff format, it’s important to consider the true end goal. As crazy as it sounds, our goal is not to score the most fantasy points. Our goal is to win this crazily formatted game that requires us to do 4 very low probability things in a row. Just because later teams score more points does not mean they give us our best shot at winning this tournament. They raise our projection, but they raise the projection of every other team too. If we draft smartly and target the right archetypes of players, drafting early can give us access to “Super Teams” that not only project better than nearly every other team in the tournament, but they are significantly more unique. We might be able to get a strongly projected team later in the year too, but simply by drafting earlier in the offseason, we probably get a projection edge, and we have access to a huge uniqueness edge.

Risk of Ruin

Of course, a huge part of this decision for each drafter is your own personal risk management. Naturally, the earlier you draft, the greater risk of ruin each team you draft has. Early in the offseason, we simply do not have the information that we will have later on depth charts, playing time, and usage which can lead to some picks we may look back at down the road and laugh about. You’ll almost certainly have drafted some players that got cut.

You also have to deal with the natural chaos of the NFL off-season. Typically that revolves around injuries, as we saw last year with someone like Cam Akers. If you drafted him before his injury, that team was obviously pretty much dead. We also do see other situations arise like suspensions and trades that totally shake up the landscape, and there are a few different situations this year that fall in the bucket.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with taking a more risk averse approach and waiting until closer to the season so that you can avoid many of these potential landmines. It’s just important to know that these tournaments with top heavy payout structures, 10+% rake and plenty of strong opponents are probably not for the super risk averse. If you’re playing them for fear of losing, it might just be best to stick to the standard 12 team league. We’re all playing this shooting for the 7 figure top prizes, and to reach that goal you’re going to need some insanely good luck. So you’re going to need to embrace some level of risk.

Multitude of Tournament Options

Last year at this time, we would have laughed at this, but we saw in 2021 that the thirst for best ball tournaments is absolutely exploding. We saw Underdog launch their Best Ball Mania II tournament and proceed to fill not one, not two but three $5 tournaments later in the offseason, as well as a $250 tournament. DraftKings filled several, and so did Drafters.

We as players now have more options than we could ever want, especially as Best Ball continues to grow, to balance out our portfolio. If you tend to lean more towards the risk averse side or just generally prefer the benefits of drafting later, you are going to have tournaments like we saw with the “Puppies” on Underdog last year that are opened AND filled later in the draft cycle. There is such an extensive menu of options for tournaments now with multiple tournaments on every site (and at different price points), that I think it really benefits drafters to dabble in multiple different timings of drafts no matter their general belief on which is more “optimal”.

Plus, drafting is fun. Who wants to sit on their hands until August when so many people are having fun drafting and arguing about running backs vs. wide receivers?

Previous Post

Maximizing Playoff Upside for Best Ball Tournaments

Next Post

Draft Like You’re Right – Fantasy Football & Best Ball Draft Strategy

Next Post
Draft Like You’re Right – Fantasy Football & Best Ball Draft Strategy

Draft Like You're Right - Fantasy Football & Best Ball Draft Strategy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Ultimate Resource to CRUSH your Best Ball Drafts.

We created the first ever suite of tools, rankings, strategy and analysis specifically dedicated to Best Ball.

Built by Best Ball players for Best Ball Players, the Spike Week tools were crafted to solve the problems we all had as drafters. Whether that’s the DraftIQ Exposure and Portfolio tool to help you see anything and everything about your teams and player combinations on EVERY site, the Draft Buddy Browser Overlays to make drafting so much easier or simply rankings and strategy designed specifically for Best Ball tournaments – not just standard fantasy advice.

If you aren’t satisfied with the product for any reason, just shoot us an email or contact Erik Beimfohr directly in our Free Discord, and we will refund you within the first 48 hours.

GET ACCESS NOW

Already a subscriber?

Lost your password?

Problem Gambling

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, crisis counseling and referral services can be accessed by calling 1-800-GAMBLER (1-800-426-2537) (IL). Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (NJ/WV/PA/MI), 1-800-9-WITH-IT (IN), 1-800-522-4700 (CO), 1-800-BETS OFF (IA), 1-888-532-3500 (VA) or call/text TN REDLINE 1-800-889-9789 (TN).

Search SpikeWeek

No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
  • Tools
    • DraftIQ
      • NFL
      • NBA
      • MLB
      • PGA
      • CFB
      • CBB
      • NHL
    • Draft Hacker
    • Tournament DB
      • NFL
      • NBA
      • MLB
    • My Draft Planner
    • Tournament Selector
    • Ownership Projections
    • Playoff Schedule Cheat Sheet
      • NFL
      • CFB
    • Bye Week Cheat Sheet
      • NFL
      • CFB
    • NFL Stack Matrix
    • Stats
      • Best Ball Stats
      • Spike Week Stats
      • Player Weekly Scores
  • Rankings
    • Rankings Hub
      • NFL
      • NBA
      • MLB
      • PGA
      • CFB
      • CBB
    • NFL
      • Underdog
      • Drafters
      • DraftKings
      • FastDraft
      • 2025 Rookie Rankings
    • NBA
      • Underdog
      • DraftKings
      • Drafters
    • MLB
      • Underdog
      • Draftkings
      • Drafters
    • PGA
      • Underdog
    • CBB
      • Underdog
    • CFB
      • Underdog
  • Strategy
    • 2025 NFL Strategy Hub
    • NFL
      • Underdog
      • Drafters
      • DraftKings
      • FastDraft
      • Zero RB Draft Strategy
      • Hero RB Draft Strategy
      • SuperHero RB Draft Strategy
      • Robust RB Draft Strategy
      • Contingent Value for NFL Best Ball
      • How to Draft Like You’re Right
      • Maximizing Playoff Upside for Best Ball Tournaments
      • Scenario Based Upside
      • The Moneyball Approach to NFL Best Ball
      • How to Auto Draft NFL Teams
      • Exploitative Best Ball Strategy
      • The Best Ball Triple Option
      • How to Use the NFL Schedule & Playoff Stacking
    • NBA
      • How to Play NBA Best Ball Tournaments
      • How to Play Underdog NBA Playoff Best Ball
      • 2025 Underdog Playoff Best Ball Strategy
      • 2025 Drafters Playoff Best Ball Strategy
      • Team Breakdown for 2025 NBA Playoff Best Ball
      • My 2025 NBA Playoff Bracket
      • Underdog NBA Data Driven Strategy Guide
    • MLB
      • How to Play MLB Best Ball
      • Underdog MLB Data Driven Strategy Guide
      • How To Play MLB Playoff Best Ball
    • PGA
      • How to Play PGA Golf Best Ball
  • Promos
    • Drafters Promo Code (100% Deposit Bonus)
    • Free Month of Spike Week w/ Drafters Deposit
    • Underdog Fantasy Promo (100% Bonus)
  • Tools Tutorials
    • How to Install the Draft Hacker
    • How to Update the Draft Hacker
    • How to Sync Your Underdog Account to the Draft Hacker
    • How to Customize Your Draft Hacker Settings
    • How to use the Draft Hacker in your Drafts
    • How to Upload Your Best Ball Teams to the Draft Hacker
    • Mobile Draft Hacker Tutorial
    • DraftIQ
      • DraftIQ Basics
  • Draft Hacker Settings
  • Subscribe
    • Discord Only
  • Account
  • Log In

© 2021 Spike Week

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?